‘I want to put him in front of an 18-wheeler’: Man irate after brother legally took widowed mother’s US$96K inheritance — Dave Ramsey chimes in

A man from Long Island, NY, called into The Ramsey Show and revealed that his family has fractured after some mischevious financial dealings came to light. After his father died, he convinced his 81-year-old widowed mother to place her US$96,000 inheritance into a certificate of deposit (CD) to keep it safe.

When he later checked the account balance, he discovered the funds were gone. His brother — listed as a joint owner — had withdrawn every cent from his mother’s CD.

After taking the money, the brother cut off all contact.

The caller and his mother are completely devastated. He asked Dave Ramsey (1) whether he should take the matter to court.

“I couldn’t care less if he’s pissed off,” Ramsey said. “I want to put him in front of an 18-wheeler.”

Ramsey stressed that, from a legal standpoint, the brother may have done nothing wrong.

His mother's money was in a joint account, and Canadian and U.S. banks operate similarly: any joint account holder (2) can withdraw the full balance at any time unless restricted by a formal agreement.

A family decision with unintended consequences

The caller explained that his mother had undergone surgery for a brain tumour and struggled with her health. After their father passed away, they suggested placing the inheritance into an auto-renewing CD for security.

To keep administrative matters simple, he added his brother’s name to the account — assuming all siblings would split the money equally later.

“We thought it'd be like an easy split, putting it on a CD. I didn't think of anything else,” he said.

The brothers fell out in October. Months after their conflict, the caller learned that his brother had withdrawn the inheritance in March 2024.

The bank confirmed that, because it is a joint account, either owner has full legal authority to remove all funds.

“You guys were so dumb. You put his name on it… I’m not sure it’s legally stealing because his name was on the account.” Ramsey said.

The financial guru noted that while the mother could hire a lawyer, it likely wouldn’t succeed. Similarly in Canada, if a family pursued a civil case, joint ownership usually supersedes verbal agreements or informal expectations.

If the perpetrator spent the money, a judgment likely won’t recover it.

“Courts don’t make people have money when they don’t have money,” Ramsey said. “You’re going to spend $10,000 chasing your mom’s money.”

The caller said his mother — who relies on disability assistance and government subsidies — does not want a long legal battle. Ramsey agreed that emotionally and practically, the best option may be to walk away.

Sponsored

Smart investing starts here

Build your own investment portfolio with CIBC Investor’s Edge online and mobile trading platform. Enjoy low commissions on trades and special pricing for active traders, students and young investors.

Get started today

Why situations like this are more common than Canadians realize

Family-perpetrated financial exploitation is difficult to prove (3) because victims sign account forms without understanding the legal context.

According to the National Council on Aging, family members are involved in nearly 47% of incidents of elder abuse (4). Additionally, the Government of Canada notes how (5) elder-abuse networks are the most common form of financial abuse in the country.

Once an adult child is a joint account holder, they become the co-owner of the funds.

How Canadian families can avoid similar mistakes

Here are some ways Canadian families can avoid the same fate:

• Avoid joint family accounts: Joint accounts grant full ownership and withdrawal rights (6) to all account holders. Instead, ask your financial institution about “transfer on death” (TOD) (7) or “payable on death” mechanisms.
• Have formal estate-planning documents: Estate planning eliminates confusion and protects seniors from accidental and intentional financial harm. At minimum, families should establish a legally drafted will, a power of attorney for property, executor instructions and asset lists.
• Review accounts and documents: Families should review account ownership and beneficiary designations after significant events such as the death of a spouse, illness and changes in family dynamics.

In the end, the emotional fallout for this family may last far longer than the financial loss — and serve as a warning for families to protect aging parents with clarity, documentation and professional advice before any problems arise.

Article sources

We rely only on vetted sources and credible third-party reporting. For details, see our editorial ethics and guidelines.

The Ramsey Show (1); Government of Canada (2); BMO (3); National Council on Aging (4); Government of Canada (5); Nelligan Law (6); RBHF (7)