A very un-Canadian sale: Rethinking Black Friday

For years, Black Friday has been treated as the unofficial kickoff to the holiday shopping season. The idea arrived in Canada from the United States, where the Friday after American Thanksgiving is known for early morning lineups, doorcrasher deals and crowded malls.

In Canada, the event has no cultural connection. Thanksgiving was last month and the holiday season unfolds differently here. Yet retailers continue to promote Black Friday as if it were a national tradition rather than an imported marketing tactic.

This year Canadians are heading into the holidays with tight budgets, rising costs and real desire to Buy Canadian. Statistics Canada reported that retail prices for many household essentials remain elevated compared with pre-pandemic levels, and the annual inflation rate has held above the Bank of Canada’s 2% target (1) for most of the year.

With shoppers watching every dollar, the pressure to “save” by shopping Black Friday sales is strong. But consumer data shows the deals promoted in late November are rarely unique to that day and shoppers have more choices and control than they think.

The real origins of Black Friday

Despite the way it is marketed, Black Friday has no connection to Canadian tradition or holidays. The term gained popularity in the United States in the 1960s when police in Philadelphia used it to describe the heavy traffic and crowded streets that followed American Thanksgiving. Retailers later reframed it as a day when stores moved “into the black” financially.

The event is tied entirely to the American holiday calendar. Canada has its own Thanksgiving in October and no historical retail behaviour tied to the last Friday of November. Its adoption here is the result of cross-border competition, not cultural relevance. As retailers expanded online and Canadians began shopping more frequently from U.S. stores, the event spread northward. The name, timing and sense of urgency remain fundamentally American.

Sponsored

Smart investing starts here

Build your own investment portfolio with CIBC Investor’s Edge online and mobile trading platform. Enjoy low commissions on trades and special pricing for active traders, students and young investors.

Get started today

A sale that isn’t really a sale

Research firms that track retail pricing trends say Black Friday does not reliably offer the lowest prices of the season. Analysts at Adobe (2) and other retail trackers in the United States have found that the average discount has narrowed in recent years as retailers shift to longer promotional periods.

In Canada, that trend is even more pronounced. Because the event is not tied to a national holiday or long weekend, retailers here often start promotional pricing earlier in November and continue it through December.

Statistics Canada’s monthly retail trade data (3) shows that discounting around Black Friday is part of a broader pattern that includes pre-holiday promotions, Boxing Week sales and January clearances. For many categories, including electronics, apparel and household goods, the lowest prices often appear in the final two weeks of December or early in the new year when stores are clearing unsold inventory.

The psychology of urgency

The marketing structure of Black Friday is designed to create a sense of urgency even when it is not warranted. Limited time banners, countdown clocks and “doorcrasher” framing leads shoppers to feel that they must act quickly. Consumer behaviour research from institutions including the University of Toronto (4) has shown that time pressure increases the likelihood of impulse purchases, especially in categories where consumers feel less informed about pricing.

That urgency is less effective when shoppers recognize that the sale is part of a long promotional season. Many retailers quietly extend their Black Friday prices through the weekend before Cyber Monday (the online sibling of Black Friday, which, quite frankly, is always available online anyway) and then again into early December. Some stores adjust prices across the month to match competitors. In practice, the window to get a deal is far wider than the marketing suggests.

Sponsored

Take control of your money with Monarch

Simplify your finances with Monarch, the all-in-one app designed to help you budget, track spending, and hit your goals faster. For a limited time, get 50% off your first year with code WISE50.

Start your free trial today

A Canadian approach to holiday budgeting

Canadians are increasingly conscious of how marketing influences spending. A survey from the Retail Council of Canada (5) shows that shoppers have been planning holiday budgets earlier each year and many say they compare prices over longer periods rather than relying on a single event.

Shoppers who want to stay on budget can benefit from a basic plan that does not depend on Black Friday. Create a list of holiday needs, set a spending limit for each category and track prices over time. Many Canadian retailers display historical pricing or offer price-match policies that remove the need to chase a single event. Stores often honour lower prices within a defined period if an item drops further after purchase.

Online tools that track price history can help shoppers see whether a claimed discount is actually a deal. These tools do not replace comparison shopping but they provide a clearer view of what products typically cost across the season.

Elbows Up! You don’t have to buy in

Black Friday may be louder in Canada than it once was but it remains an American event at its core. Canadians do not need to adopt the urgency that surrounds it or feel left behind if they skip the sales. The holiday season is long, the promotional period is longer and the best deals rarely depend on a single day.

A thoughtful approach to spending and a clear understanding of when prices actually drop can offer better savings than any doorcrasher sale. This year, the elbows-up approach to shopping can give way to something more practical. Canadians can opt out of the consumerist pressure while still getting what they need at prices that make sense.

Article sources

We rely only on vetted sources and credible third-party reporting. For details, see our editorial ethics and guidelines.

Statistics Canada (1), (3); Adobe (2); University of Toronto (4); Retail Council of Canada (5)