Snowbirds rethink the U.S. as border rules, costs and politics collide

For decades, the Canadian snowbird routine barely changed. Retire, pack up the car or book a flight and follow the sun south until spring thawed the driveway back home.

This winter, many retirees are pausing. Not cancelling travel altogether but reassessing where their dollars, time and peace of mind are best spent.

A mix of new U.S. entry requirements, a weaker loonie and political rhetoric aimed at Canada has made the annual migration feel more complicated. According to a poll by Snowbird Advisor (1), 15% of respondents said they no longer plan to travel to the United States this winter, a notable shift for a group that has long returned to the same destinations year after year.

New rules are creating anxiety, not clarity

Last spring, the U.S. began enforcing additional requirements for foreign nationals staying longer than 30 days, including biometric data collection at some ports of entry and an alien registration process visitors are expected to carry proof of. The Canadian Snowbird Association says its members have reported inconsistent experiences at land borders, adding to confusion.

For Paul MacLellan of Oshawa, ON, that uncertainty became the deciding factor. After eight winters in Myrtle Beach, S.C., he and his wife Debbie are sitting this one out (2).

“We had to do that online and it wasn’t easy to do and we weren’t sure whether we’d done it right,” MacLellan told CTV of the registration process. “So then we’re always feeling maybe there’s a threat we were going to get pulled over because of our licence plate and we maybe we didn’t have the paperwork. It was just an uneasy feeling.”

Instead, the couple is redirecting their winter budget closer to home and overseas.

“We got this extra money we’re not using, so we might as well spend it up here,” he said.

Sponsored

Smart investing starts here

Build your own investment portfolio with CIBC Investor’s Edge online and mobile trading platform. Enjoy low commissions on trades and special pricing for active traders, students and young investors.

Get started today

Others say the experience on the ground feels unchanged

Not everyone is staying north of the border. Some snowbirds say the headlines have been louder than the reality.

Richard Reid, who has spent 10 winters in Mesa, Ariz., says his latest border crossing was uneventful.

“That probably took us less time to go through at the border crossing in Vancouver this year than it had in any previous years,” he told CTV.

Once settled in Arizona, he says the anxiety faded quickly.

“Once we got here and said hi to all our mostly American friends… it was just like we’d never left.”

Safety and values are part of the calculation

For others, the decision is about more than paperwork or exchange rates.

Jan Vallillee, recently retired in Yellowknife, decided against the U.S. this winter after friends changed their plans. As a member of the LGBTQ2S+ community, she says personal safety weighs heavily. “We are part of a minority group and it seems like the current administration in the United States appears to have a little bit of an issue with various minority groups,” Vallillee told CTV. “Safety is key.”

She also pointed to the emotional toll of travelling somewhere that feels politically hostile.

“It has nothing to do with the population. It has everything to do with the current administration. And fear.”

Sponsored

Take control of your money with Monarch

Simplify your finances with Monarch, the all-in-one app designed to help you budget, track spending, and hit your goals faster. For a limited time, get 50% off your first year with code WISE50.

Start your free trial today

Where snowbirds are taking their dollars instead

Mexico, Portugal, Belize, Southeast Asia and even Canadian destinations are seeing increased interest from retirees opting out of the U.S. this year. For many, affordability plays a role. With the Canadian dollar under pressure, destinations where the loonie stretches further are appealing.

Carolyn Riley of the Ottawa Valley told CTV her last Florida trip felt different.

“It just didn’t feel good hearing that sort of thing from people that you had known for the last three years,” she said, referring to comments she heard after President Donald Trump was sworn into office. This winter, she and her husband are heading to Mexico.

“We like warm weather, and of course the dollar is pretty good,” Riley said.

A service check before you book

If you are weighing your own snowbird plans, a few practical steps can help reduce stress and avoid costly mistakes:

• Confirm U.S. stay requirements directly with U.S. Customs and Border Protection, including biometric screening and registration expectations
• Carry proof of compliance if staying longer than 30 days, including any registration confirmation
• Factor in currency risk when budgeting long stays. A five or 10 cent swing in the loonie can materially affect a multi month rental
• Review travel insurance carefully, especially coverage tied to trip length and destination
• Consider alternatives where visa rules are clearer or the Canadian dollar goes further, particularly for fixed income retirees

For some, like Judy McConnell of Saskatchewan, the choice is straightforward.

“We’ve spent a lot of money on this motor home and we need to use it,” she told CTV. “We are still going to go into the States no matter what the political climate is.”

For others, this winter is about trying something new or simply staying put. Either way, the era of autopilot snowbirding appears to be over, replaced by more careful planning and, for many retirees, tougher questions about where they feel welcome, safe and financially comfortable.

Article sources

We rely only on vetted sources and credible third-party reporting. For details, see our editorial ethics and guidelines.

Snowbird Advisor (1); CTV News (2)